Liability for harm caused by minors: A comparative legal study
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.21638/spbu25.2023.405Abstract
The article examines the tort obligations arising in the case of harm to minors under the age of 14. The experience of countries whose legislation does not provide for a general rule on the indelicitability of a minor is studied; it is concluded that in these countries, judicial practice also takes into account the ability or inability of a minor to understand the illegality of his actions or the likelihood of harm. When determining the persons responsible for the harm caused to minors, it was suggested that persons exercising supervision on the basis of a contract should not be understood as relatives or family friends looking after a child as a gratuitous service. On the contrary, commercial organizations that equip a place for children to play automatically become obliged to exercise supervision; as well as persons who, on the basis of a paid contract, provide educational, entertainment, medical, and other similar services to a child. By contracts, by virtue of which a person is obliged to exercise supervision, it is proposed to understand either paid contracts or gratuitous contracts accompanying the process of concluding a paid contract with a consumer (children’s rooms in department stores, restaurants, and so on). The necessity of bringing to responsibility for the harm caused to minors, not only parents, but also persons actually engaged in education (which include, for example, the stepfather or stepmother of the child) is discussed.
Keywords:
tort, parental care, responsibility, incapacity of minors, compensation for harm
Downloads
References
Afanasyevskaya, Anna V. 2022. On the issue of civil liability of minors. Siberian Legal Review 3: 245–252.
Albilt, Hans-Joachim. 1987. Haften Eltern für ihre Kinder? Pfaffenweiler, Centaurus-Verlagsgesellschaft.
Albrecht, Anette. 2013. Die deliktische Haftung für fremdes Verhalten im französischen und deutschen Recht Eine rechtsvergleichende Untersuchung unter besonderer Berücksichtigung der Blieck-Rechtsprechung der Cour de cassation. Tortious Liability for the Behavior of Another Person in French and German Law. A Comparative Study Focusing on the Blieck Ruling by the Cour de cassation XVIII: 175.
Busnelli, Francesco D., Comandé, Giovanni, Cousy, Herman, Dobbs, Dan B., Dufwa, Bill W., Faure, Michael G., Gilead, Israel, Green, Michael D., Kerameus, Konstantinos D., Bernhard A. Koch, Koziol, Helmut, Magnus, Ulrich, Martín-Casals, Miquel, Moréteau, Olivier, Neethling, Johann, Rogers, W. V. Horton, Monteiro, Jorge Ferreira Sinde, Spier, Jaap, Tichy Lubos, Widmer, Pierre. 2005. Principles of European Tort Law: Text and Commentary. Springer Vienna.
Codification of Russian civil law: The Code of Civil Laws of the Russian Empire, the Draft Civil Code of the Russian Empire, the Civil Code of the RSFSR of 1922, the Civil Code of 1964. 2003. Ekaterinburg: Institut chastnogo prava Publ. (In Russian)
Ennekzerus, Ludwig, Kipp, Theodor, Wolf, Martin. 1949. The course of German civil law. Transl. from the 13th German edition by K. A. Grave [et al.]; ed., preface and introd. remarks by D. M. Genkin, I. B. Novitsky. Vol. 1, half volume 1: Introduction and general part. Moscow, Izdatelstvo inostrannoy literaturi. (In Russian)
French Civil Code. Sci. ed. and forew. by D. G. Lavrov, transl. from the French by A. A. Zhukova, G. A. Pashkovskaya. 2004. St. Petersburg, Iuridicheskii Tsentr Press. (In Russian)
Frolov, Igor V. 2022. Recognition of individuals as debtors in bankruptcy cases: on the issue of the concept of the citizen’s competitiveness. Competition Law 4: 29–34.
Hrádek, Jiří. 2006. Children as Tortfeasors under Czech Law. Tort and Insurance Law. SpringerVerlag Vienna: 111–146.
Jourdain, Patrice. 2021. Principles of civil liability. Bulletin of Civil Law 4: 212–241. (In Russian)
Jourdain, Patrice. 2021. Principles of civil liability. Bulletin of Civil Law 5: 233–255. (In Russian)
Jourdain, Patrice. 2021. Principles of civil liability. Bulletin of Civil Law 6: 154–193. (In Russian)
Jourdain, Patrice. 2022. Principles of civil liability. Bulletin of Civil Law 1: 200–229. (In Russian)
McIvor, Claire M. 1999. Reforming the English law on parental liability: a comparison with the French experience. Durham, Durham University. Available at: http://www.etheses.dur.ac.uk/4589/ (accessed: 15.01.2023).
Miquel, Martín-Casals. 2006. Comparative Report. Children in Tort Law. Part I: Children as Tortfeasors. Vol. 17. Tort and Insurance Law. Ed. by М.-С. Miquel. Vienna, Springer-Verlag: 423–467. https://doi.org/10.1007/3-211-31132-7
Pokrovsky, Ioseph. A. 1998. The main problems of civil law. Moscow, Statut Publ.
Porter, Elizabeth G. 2013. Tort Liability in the Age of the Helicopter Parent (February 1, 2012). Alabama Law Review 64, 3. Available at: https://www.ssrn.com/abstract=2166491 (accessed: 15.01.2023).
Rambach, Peter H. 1994. Die deliktische Haftung Minderjähriger und ihrer Eltern im französischen, belgischen und deutschen Deliktsrecht. Ius commune. Antwerpen, Maklu.
Ruzanova, Evgenia V. 2013. Obligations as a result of harm caused with the participation of minor citizens. PhD diss. abstract. Saratov. (In Russian)
Sanfilippo, Cesare. 2007. Course Roman private law: textbook. Transl. by Ital. I. I. Mahanykova, ed. by D. V. Dojdeva. Moscow, Norma Publ. (In Russian)
Scheffen, Erika. 1995. Reform proposals on the liability of children and adolescents. Festschrift for Erich Steffen on the occasion of his 65th birthday on May 28, 1995. The compensation for damages and its coverage. Ed. by E. Deutsch, E. Klingmüller, H. J. Kullmann. Berlin, New York. (In German)
Scott, Leonard. 1988. Liability of Parents for Conduct of Their Child Under Section 33.01 of the Texas
Family Code: Defining the Requisite Standards of ‘Culpability’. St. Mary’s Law Journal 20: 69–92. Available at: https://www.ssrn.com/abstract=2892406 (accessed: 15.01.2023).
Tavernier, Pieter. 2006. De Children as Tortfeasors under Belgian Law. Children in Tort Law. Part I: Children as Tortfeasors. Vol. 17. Tort and Insurance Law. Ed. by М.-С. Miquel. Vienna, SpringerVerlag: 63–110.
Veloso, Maria M. Children as Tortfeasors under Portuguese Law. Children in Tort Law. Part I: Children as Tortfeasors. Vol. 17. Tort and Insurance Law. Ed. by М.-С. Miquel. Vienna, Springer-Verlag: 311–344.
Waitzmann, Steffen. Das Eltern-Kind-Verhältnis im Schadensrecht. Haften Kinder für ihre Eltern?
Zur Frage der Haftung von Kindern für ein Fehlverhalten ihrer Eltern im Zusammenhang mit dem Gedanken des Minderjährigenschutzes und der Tendenz zur Beschränkung der Minderjährigenhaftung. Inaugural — Dissertation. Universität Tübingen, 2002.
Yakushev, Pavel A. 2021. Determining the order of communication between parents and a child in Germany: some aspects of legislation and judicial practice. Family and housing law 6: 28–30. (In Russian)
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Articles of "Pravovedenie" are open access distributed under the terms of the License Agreement with Saint Petersburg State University, which permits to the authors unrestricted distribution and self-archiving free of charge.
