Purchase and sale and prohibition of uncertainty (gharar) in the Islamic tradition
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.21638/spbu25.2022.203Abstract
The article deals with the requirements of Islamic law to the classical contract of sale. The authors conclude that the prescriptions regarding the conclusion of a contract of sale, the object of sale and price formation are largely explained by the attraction of Islam to fairness in trade. Analyzing the object of sale, the authors refer to the concept of property al-mal and its forms — al-‘ayn property and al-dayn property. They insist that al-dayn is not an analogue of “obligation”, “debt” or “right of claim” in the civilian or common law’s traditions, but a unique concept of Islamic law, literally meaning “property-in-the-future”. Considering limitations to sale of aldayn property, this article presents the approaches of madhhabs regarding the admissibility of and conditions for the sale and purchase of bay’ al-dayn. The basic tool of Islamic law on its way to a sustainable trade turnover is the prohibition of transactions involving excessive uncertainty gharar. The authors reveal the meaning of this concept, which has been widely discussed among Muslim scholars, and distinguish the notion of gharar from the notions of risk and gambling maysīr. Application of gharar prohibition to the contract of sale has its own characteristics and gharar becomes key point in deciding whether it is admissible to sell a non-existent thing — bai‘ al-ma‘dum and sell a thing that is not available for physical inspection at the time of the transaction — bai‘ al-ghayb. In this context, the authors pay attention to the distance sale of goods by preliminary inspection, by sample and by description. Islamic law offers an effective mechanism for removing the uncertainty gharar from the contract of sale, giving the buyer the right of khiyar al-ru’yah, which is the right to unilaterally withdraw from the contract at the moment of physical inspection of the goods.
Keywords:
sale (bay’), sale of non-existent (bai‘ al-ma‘dum), sale of goods in absentia (bai‘ alghayb), property (al-mal), contract (aqd), uncertainty (gharar), Islamic law
Downloads
References
Abdullah, Atikullah H. 2013. The Elements of Qimar (wagering) and Gharar (uncertainty) in the Contract of Insurance Revisited. Journal of Islamic Economics, Banking and Finance 9 (2): 91–92.
Ahmedov, Aibek. 2010. The problem of the influence of Roman law on Muslim law. Drevnee pravo. Ivs antiqvvm 1 (25): 76–86. (In Russian)
Akhmedzhanov, Utkura M. 1963. The institution of property in Islamic law: PhD dissertation. Moscow, Lomonosov Moscow State University. (In Russian)
Al-Amine, Muhammad B. M. 2008. Risk Management in Islamic Finance: An Analysis of Derivatives Instruments in Commodity Markets. Brill’s Arab and Islamic laws series. Vol. 1. Leiden, Boston: Brill.
Al-Dhareer, Siddiq M. A. 1997. Al-Gharar in contracts and its effect on contemporary transactions. Eminent Scholar’s Lecture Series 16. Jeddah, Research and Training Institute, Islamic Development Bank.
Ali, Ariffhidayat. 2010. Islamic Law of Contract. Enforcement of Islamic Contracts: Issues in the Light of Contemporary Legal Frameworks — FQ 6133. International Centre for Education in Islamic Finance (INCEIF). Term Paper: PhD Program: 12–14. Available at: http://www.iefpedia.com/english/wp-content/uploads/2011/03/ILC_ASSIGNMENT_AA2.pdf accessed: 25.08.2022).
Ali, Engku R. A. E. 2003. Re-Defining Property and Property Rights in Islamic Law of Contract. Jurnal Syariah 11 (2): 47–60.
Alieva, Naida A. 2013. Just price in the islamic economic thought. Problemy sovremennoi ekonomiki 4 (48): 433–435. (In Russian)
Al-Juzairi, Abd R. ibn M. A. 2017. The Laws of Trade in the Four Madhhabs. St Petersburg, Dilya Publ. (In Russian)
Almezeini, Abduaziz А. 2014. The Negotiability of Debt in Islamic Finance: an Analytical and Critical Study: A Doctoral Thesis on Juridical Science. Georgetown, Georgetown University Law Center.
Al-Misri, Rafik Yu. 2014. Fiqh of property relations, transl. from Arabic D. Adgi. Moscow, Islamskaia kniga Publ. (In Russian)
al-Saadi, Abd R. N. 2002. The Joy of the Hearts of the Pious: An Explanation of the Brief but Meaningful Words of the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him), transl. from Arabic V. A. Nirsh. Moscow, Ibragim Bin Abdulaziz Al’ Ibragim Publ. (In Russian)
Al-Saati, Abdul-Rahim. 2003. The Permissible Gharar (Risk) in Classical Islamic Jurisprudence. J.KAU: Islamic Economics 16 (2). al-Sadr, Muhammad B. 2009. History of ‘Ilm Al-Usul. Moscow, Sadra Publ. (In Russian)
Al-Said, Fahad A. M. 1992. Territorial behaviour and the built environment: the case of Arab-Muslim towns, Saudi Arabia: A Doctoral Thesis in Philosophy. Glasgow, University of Glasgow. an-Nawawi, Jahja. Sh. 2015. 40 hadith, transl. from Arabic, comm. N. M. Abdul. Moscow, Eksmo. (In Russian)
Ayub, Muhammad. 2007. Understanding Islamic Finance. Chichester, John Wiley & Sons. Badawi, Zaki. 2007. Contract for Selling Unseen (Bai Al Ma’dum — The sale of unseen goods). Al-Huda Centre of Islamic Banking & Economics (CIBE). Issue 001. Available at: http://www.alhudacibe.com/newsletter/1-15dec/article_15.html (accessed: 19.05.2021).
Bearman, Peri J., Bianquis, Thierry, Bosworth, Clifford E., Donzel, Emeri van, Heinrichs, Wolfhart P.(eds) 2000. The Encyclopedia of Islam. New Edition. In 12 vols. Vol. X: T–U. Leiden, E. J. Brill.
Bearman, Peri J., Bianquis, Thierry, Bosworth, Clifford E., Donzel, Emeri van, Heinrichs, Wolfhart P. (eds) 2004. The Encyclopedia of Islam. New Edition. In 12 vols. Vol. XII: Supplement. Leiden, E. J. Brill.
Bekkin, Renat. 2008. Theoretical Origins of Islamic Economic Doctrine in the Middle Ages. Pax Islamica 1: 99–123. (In Russian)
Bespalova, Olga V. 2016. Distinctive features of the concepts of “uncertainty”, “risk”. Pozharnaia besopasnost’: problemy i perspektivy 2 (1): 84–86. (In Russian)
Bilal, Gohar. 1999. Islamic Tradable Instruments Basic Building Blocks. Proceedings of the Second Harvard University Forum on Islamic Finance: Islamic Finance into the 21st Century. Cambridge, Massachusetts, Center for Middle Eastern Studies, Harvard University: 140–144.
Bosworth, Clifford E., Donzel, Emeri van, Heinrichs, Wolfhart P., Pellat, Charles (eds). 1993. The Encyclopedia of Islam. New Edition. In 12 vols. Vol. VII: MIF–NAZ. Leiden, E. J. Brill.
Bosworth, Clifford E., Donzel, Emeri van, Lewis, Bernard, Pellat, Charles (eds). 1991. The Encyclopedia of Islam. New Edition. In 12 vols. Vol. VI: MAHK–MID. Leiden, E. J. Brill.
Cattelan, Valentino. 2013. Property (Māl) and Credit Relations in Islamic Law: An Explanation of Dayn and the Function of Legal Personality (Dhimma). Arab Law Quarterly 27.
Davaba, Ashraf M. 2017. The blessed work of a Muslim. Useful knowledge for Muslim business people: trade, property, income management, charity for the benefit of the community, the state and oneself. Moscow, Eksmo Publ. (In Russian)
Donzel, Emeri van, Lewis, Bernard, Pellat, Charles (eds). 1997. The Encyclopedia of Islam. New Edition. In 12 vols. Vol. IV: IRAN–KHA. Leiden, E. J. Brill.
Ehsan, Muhammad A. 2014. Futures Contracts in Islamic Finance: A Jurisprudential Analysis. Journal of Islamic Economics, Banking 10 (1): 156–181.
Elfakhani, Said, Sidani, Yusuf, M. 2015. Uncertainty or ‘gharar’ in contracts under the Islamic ethical code. The Handbook of Research on Islamic Business Ethics, ed. A. J. Ali. Cheltenham, Edward Elgar Publishing: 134–135.
El-Gamal, Mahmoud. A. 2001. An economic explication of the prohibition of gharar in classical Islamic jurisprudence. Islamic Economic Studies 8 (2): 30–33.
Ghazanfar, Shaikh. M., Islahi, Abdul A. 2003. Explorations in medieval Arab Islamic economic thought: some aspects of Ibn Qayyim’s economics (AH691–751/1292–1350AD). Medieval Islamic economic thought: filling the “Great Gap” in European economics, ed. by Shaikh M. Ghazanfar. London; New York: Routledge/Curzon.
Gibb, Hamilton A. R., Kramers, Johannes H., Lévi-Provençal, Évariste, Schacht, Joseph (eds). 1986. The Encyclopedia of Islam. New Edition. In 12 vols. Vol. I: A–B. Leiden, E. J. Brill.
Hallaq, Wael. 2020. History of Islamic theories of law. Introduction to Sunni Legal Theory, transl. from English I. A. Tsaregorodtsev, scien. ed. I. L. Alekseev. Moscow, HSE Publishing House. (In Russian)
Hassan, Abdullah A. H. 1986. Sales and contracts in early Islamic commercial law: A Doctoral Thesis in Philosophy. Edinburgh, University of Edinburgh.
Iqbal, Munawar. 2013. Islamic finance: An attractive new way of financial intermediation. International Journal of Banking and Finance 10 (2): 5–7.
Ishola, Abdullahi S., Azeez, Yusuf. A., Ali, Norfadhilah M. 2016. Al‑‘aqd Al‑sahih: The Legal Basis for Determining the Validity of Islamic Financial Transactions. International Journal of Economics and Financial Issues 6 (iss. S2): 140–143.
Islam, Muhammad W. 1999. Al-Mal: The Concept of Property in Islamic Legal Thought. Arab Law Quarterly 14 (4).
Jailani, Moham ad Z. Hiwalah in Shariah and its Rules and Applications in Islamic Finance: 1–11. Available at: https://www.academia.edu/26533600/Hiwalah_in_Shariah_and_its_rules_and_applications_in_Islamic_Finance (accessed: 12.06.2022).
Kabbara, Abdulrahman H. S. 1988. Islamic banking: a case study of Kuwait: A Doctoral Thesis in Philosophy. Loughborough, Loughborough University.
Kamali, Mohammad H. 1999. Uncertainty and Risk-Taking (Gharar) in Islamic Law. IIUM Law Journal 7 (2).
Kapralin, Stanislav G. 2013. Differentiation of views on the definition of “risk” and “uncertainty”. Vestnik Tomskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Ekonomika 2 (22): 33–39. (In Russian)
Karapetov, Artem G. 2014. Civil Rights Protection Models: An Economic Perspective. Part 1. Vestnik ekonomicheskogo pravosudiia 11: 24–80. (In Russian)
Karapetov, Artem G. 2016. Economic analysis of law. Moscow, Statut Publ. (In Russian)
Kazem-Bek, Aleksandr K. 1862. Sheraiul-Islam, or the Laws of Shiite Muslims. Release the first. Contains two books: On Trade and Pledge / The Work of Sheikh Abul-Gkasim, nicknamed Al-Muhagkygk. St Petersburg, Tip. Imperatorskoi Akademii Nauk Publ. (In Russian)
Khan, Muhammad A. 2003. Islamic Economics and Finance: A Glossary. London; New York: Routledge.
Knight, Frank H. 2003. Risk, uncertainty and profit. Moscow, Delo Publ. (In Russian)
Kolesnikov, Evgeny Yu. 2019. A topic of uncertainty in the publications of the journal “Issues of risk analysis”. Issues of risk analysis 16 (3): 78–93. (In Russian)
Kremer, Alfred fon. 1888. Islamic law, transl. from German R. R. Eikhgorn. Tashkent, Tip. Okr. Shtab Publ. (In Russian)
Kryuchkov, Roman A. 2011. Risk in law: genesis, concept and management: PhD Abstract. Nizhnii
Novgorod, Nizhegorodskii gosudarstvennii universitet imeni N. I. Lobachevskogo. (In Russian)
Kuzmin, Evgenii A. 2014. The problem of uncertainty as a scientific category. Effektivnoe antikrizisnoe upravlenie 3 (84): 90–100. (In Russian)
Le Goff, Jacques. 2010. The Middle Ages and Money: An Essay on Historical Anthropology. St Petersburg, Evrasia Publ. (In Russian)
Lewis, Bernard, Menage, Victor L., Pellat, Charles, Schacht, Joseph (eds). 1986. The Encyclopedia of Islam. New Edition. In 12 vols. Vol. III: H–IRAM. Leiden, E. J. Brill.
Mahmor, Shafaai M. 2000. The Conditions of the Countervalues of the Contract of Sale Under Islamic Law with Occasional Comparison with English Law: A Doctoral Thesis in Philosophy. Glasgow, Glasgow Caledonian University.
Marghīnānī, Ali ibn A. B., Hamilton, Charles, Grady, Standish G. 1957. The Hedaya, Or Guide: A Commentary on the Mussulman Laws. Lahore, New Book Co.
Marginani, Burkhanuddin. 2010. Khidoya. Muslim Law Commentaries: in 2 pts, 4 vols. Part 1. Vol. I–II, transl. from English N. I. Grodekov, scient. ed. A. Kh. Saidov. Moscow, Wolters Kluwer Publ. (In Russian)
Muhammad, Amanullah, Rahman, Habibur. 2016. Sale subject to a condition in Islamic law: a juristic analysis. Shariah Journal 24 (3): 423–444.
Nofal, Irinei G. 1886. The course of Islamic law, read in 1884/85 in the Educational Department of Oriental Languages at the Asiatic Department. Issue I: About property, transl. from French. St Petersburg, Tip. Fenke i Fyusno Publ. (In Russian)
Noor, Mohd M. M., Suliaman, Ishak, Ahmad, Khadher, Deraman, Fauzi, Abdullah, Mustaffa, Shah, Faisal A., Yusoff, Mohd Y. Z. M., Razzak, Monika M. A., Meftah, Jilani T., Ariffin, Sedek, Kasar, Ahmad K., Nor, Mohd R. M. 2013. The Rights of Khiyar (Option) in the Issue of Consumerism in Malaysia. Middle-East Journal of Scientific Research 13 (2).
Noval, Al’ Shabuti S. M. 2002. Freedom of contract under the civil law of the Republic of Yemen: PhD Diss. Moscow, Rossiiskii universitet druzhbi narodov. (In Russian)
Pacchioni, Giovanni. 2016. The concept of obligation: from F. K. von Savigny to the German Civil Code. Ius Antiquum. Drevnee pravo 2 (34): 184–209. (In Russian)
Poldnikov, Dmitrii Yu. 2010. Ethical and philosophical background of the concept “just price” in european ius commune. Vestnik Novosibirskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Seriia Pravo 6 (1): 31–36. (In Russian)
Prozorov, Stanislav M. (ed.) Islam. Encyclopedic Dictionary. 1991. Moscow, Nauka Publ. (In Russian)
Pyatov, Mikhail L. 2013. Fair value: what is it? Bukh.1S 8: 41–44. (In Russian)
Rahmatullin, Rafael Yu. 2016. Special features of Islamic law. Vestnik VEGU 5 (85): 108–109. (In Russian)
Rittenberg, Ryan M. 2014. Gharar in Post-Formative Islamic Commercial Law: A Study of the Representation of Uncertainty in Islamic Legal Thought: A Doctoral Thesis in Philosophy. Philadelphia, University of Pennsylvania.
Rosenthal, Franz. 1975. Gambling in Islam. Leiden, E. J. Brill.
Schacht, Joseph F. 1982. An Introduction to Islamic Law. New York: Oxford University Press.
Siå, Magdolna. 2006. Praviåna cena (pretium iustum) i wena primena tokom istorije. Zbornik Matice srpske za drustvene nauke 120: 199–227.
Skorobogatov, Aleksandr S. 2015. Social order as a contract between the powerful and the weak. Terra Economicus 13 (1): 43–60. (In Russian)
Smits, Maarten H. J. 2014. Efficient Breach and the enforcement of specific performance. LLM Privaatrecht. Amsterdam. Available at: http://dare.uva.nl/cgi/arno/show.cgi?fid=530114 (accessed: 24.08.2022).
Sosnenko, Liudmila S., Matveev, Boris A. 2008. The content of the concepts of “risk” and “riskiness”. Vestnik Cheliabinskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta 29: 32–38. (In Russian)
Sukhanov, Evgenii A. 2017. Property law: scientific and educational essay. Moscow, Statut Publ. (In Russian)
Taleb, Nassim N. 2018. Black Swan. Under the sign of unpredictability. Moscow, Kolibri, Azbuka-Attikus Publ. (In Russian)
Taleb, Nassim N. 2018. Risking Your Own Skin: The Hidden Asymmetries of Everyday Life. Moscow, Kolibri, Azbuka-Attikus Publ. (In Russian)
Tenberga, Inese. 2017. Prohibition of unlawful interest (riba) as grounds for the refusal from collection and payment of interest in Islamic banking. Zakon 4: 78–89. (In Russian)
Tenberga, Inese. 2020. Islamic banking and its foundations. Izvestiia Natsional’noi akademii nauk Azerbaidzhana (NANA). Seriia: Ekonomika 6: 191–200. (In Russian)
Tornau, Nikolai E. 1850. Expositions of the beginnings of Muslim jurisprudence. St Petersburg, tip. II otd. Sobstv. E. I. V. Kantseliarii Publ. (In Russian)
Tornau, Nikolai E. 1892. Features of Muslim law. St Petersburg, Tip. Imperat. Akad. nauk Publ. (In Russian)
Tornau, Nikolai E. 1882. On the right of property under Islamic law. St Petersburg, Tip. Imperat. Akad. nauk Publ. (In Russian)
Van den Berg, Ludvig. 2005. Basic Principles of Islamic Law According to the Teachings of Imams Abu Hanifa and Shafi’i. Moscow, Natalis Publ. (In Russian)
Van Erp, Sjef, Akkermans, Bram (eds). 2021. Cases, Materials and Text on Property Law. Bloomsbury Publishing. Available at: https://www.perlego.com/book/391496/cases-materials-andtext-on-property-law-pdf (accessed: 12.06.2022).
Visser, Hans. 2013. Islamic Finance: Principles and Practice. Second Edition. Cheltenham, Northampton: Edward Elgar Publishing.
Vogel, Frank E., Hayes, Samuel L. 1998. Islamic Law and Finance. Religion, Risk and Return. The Hague, Kluwer Law International.
Waheed, Khalid. 2008. A critical study of Murabahah as an Islamic mode of financing: A Doctoral Thesis in Philosophy. Aligarh, Aligarh Muslim University.
Wisham, Ismail, Muneeza, Aishath, Hassan, Rusni. 2011. Special legal features of the Islamic wa’d or pledge. Comparison with the conventional law on promise within the sphere of Islamic finance. International Journal of Law and Management 53 (3).
Zahraa, Mahdi, Mahmor, Shafaai M. 2001. Definition and Scope of the Islamic Concept of Sale of Goods. Arab Law Quarterly 16 (3): 216–218.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Articles of "Pravovedenie" are open access distributed under the terms of the License Agreement with Saint Petersburg State University, which permits to the authors unrestricted distribution and self-archiving free of charge.
