Gender discrimination in employment in China and Russia
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.21638/spbu25.2019.203Abstract
The paper researches the problem of gender equality in employment in Russia and China. Starting with the review of the general attitude on the role of the woman in the society in these countries (part 1) the authors proceed with the analysis of national norms and case law. They point that in spite of ratification by both countries of the main international instruments prohibiting gender discrimination in employment these norms did not fully penetrate to the legal system and to the legal culture of China and Russia. Part 2 focuses on the prohibition of employment of women in some occupations and the protection from gender discrimination in Russia. In the part 3 the relevant Chinese experience and legislation is investigated through the comparison with the Russian approach. In conclusions the main common traits of gender based discrimination in employment in both countries are formulated: even though they established anti-discrimination principles to ensure gender equality at the workplace, the lack of clarity in the definition of discrimination and the absence of a general provision on the shift of the burden of proof as well as the absence of norms protecting women who lodged a claim on discrimination against an employer from victimization. In both countries the authors evidence the lack of case law on discrimination and the difficulties in proving discrimination in the rare cases which were brought before the court. The authors also substantiate that the general attitude towards the division of roles between men and women is one of the main reasons of gender discrimination in both countries.
Keywords:
Chinese law, Russian law, gender, pay gap, discrimination, employment, stereotypes, labour law, special protection
Downloads
References
References
Akee R., Liqiu, Zhao, Zhong, Zhao. 2019. Unintended consequences of China’s new labor contract law on unemployment and welfare loss of the workers. China Economic Review 53: 87–105.
Ashwin, Sarah. 2004. Adapting to Russia’s New Labour Market: Gender and Employment Behaviour. Abingdon, Routledge.
Bohong, Liu, Li, Ling, Yang, Chunyu. 2015. Gender Equality in China’s Economic Transformation. United Nations System in China. Availаble at: https://un.org.cn/uploads/20180326/2063f2493b160cd25bb79ce54fe8dcc1.pdf (accessed: 20.06.2019). (In Chinese)
Chirin, Vladislav. 2019. The St. Petersburg court declared the dismissal of a transgender woman illegal. Available at: https://paperpaper.ru/peterburgskij-sud-priznal-nezakonny/ (accessed: 20.06.2019). (In Russian)
Du, Kang. 2014. On Sexism Phenomenon in Graduate Employment. Guangdong jìshu shifan xueyuan xuebao (sheke kexue) 5: 56–64. (In Chinese)
Feng, Yanjun. 2004. The Multiple Denotations of Labour Rights. Dangdai faxue 2: 40–45. (In Chinese)
Gao, Zhihong. 2008. Gender discrimination in Chinese recruitment advertisements: a content analysis. Journal of Asia-Pacific business 9 (4): 395–418.
Gimpelson, Vladimir E., Kapelyushnikov, Rostislav I. 2017. Mobility and stability in the Russian labour market HSE researches. Moscow, Publishing House of the Higher School of Economics. (In Russian)
Guan, Yi-nan. 2014. The Equal Protection of Women’s Employment Rights from the Perspective of Gender Segregation: Thoughts on the Social Burden of the Relief of the Women’s Employment Rights. Rencai ziyuan kaifa 4: 21–24. (In Chinese)
Guo, Hui-min, Ding, Ning. 2006. Legislation Patterns of Sexual Equality in Employment. Zhongguo qingnian zhengzhi xueyuan xuebao 3: 116–122. (In Chinese)
Guo, Hui-min, Wang, Hui-fang. 2009. Negative Effect Analysis and the Resolution of Special Protection for Women’s Labour Rights. Hebei beida daxue xuebao zhexue shehuì kexue ban 4: 38–41. (In Chinese)
Guo, Yan-jun. 2013. Reflection on the Equal Protection System for Women’s Employment in China. Fashang yanjiu 2: 97–104. (In Chinese)
Jia, Yi-na. 2004. Causes of and Solution to the Recessive Discrimination against Women in Employment. Zhonghua nuzi xueyuan xuebao 2: 20–23. (In Chinese)
Jing, Chun-lan. 2011. A Review of Gender Essentialism in Female Labour Legislation in China. Hebei faxue 6: 146–150. (In Chinese)
Latyshevskaia, Nataliia I., Bessarabov, Aleksandr V., Novikova, Anna N., Grushko, Arkadii V. 2008. Indicators Of Reproductive Health Of Men-Workers Of Industrial Enterprises. The Bulletin Of The Volgograd Research Center of RAMS 2: 7–10. Available at: https://www.volgmed.ru/uploads/journals/articles/1257252546-bulletin-2008-2-489.pdf (accessed: 15.05.2020). (In Russian).
Li, Baocheng. 2018. Analysis of the Legal Issues of Gender Discrimination in Employment in China. Fazhi yu shehuì 32: 245–246. (In Chinese)
Lin, Yan-qin. 2011. Research about The Plight of the Protection System for Special Labour of the Female Workers and Countermeasures. Faxue zazhi 11: 59–63. (In Chinese)
Liu, Ming-hui. 2009. Negative Effects of Restriction of Women in Certain Professions. Funu yanjiu luncong 2: 43–45. (In Chinese)
Liu, Ming-hui. 2011. On the New Ideas of Legislation on Special Protection for Female Workers. Zhonghua nuzi xueyuan xuebao 5: 5–10. (In Chinese)
Liu, Ming-hui. 2014. Lack of Legislation Reflected in the First Legal Case of Gender-based Employment Discrimination. Funu yanjiu luncong 2: 44–48. (In Chinese)
Liu, Ming-hui. 2018. Legal Milestones in the Field of Female Employment — Reviewing the Gains and Losses in the Past 40 years. Zhonghua nuzi xueyuan xuebao 12 (6): 39–44. (In Chinese)
Liu, Xiaonan. 2013. Hong Kong and Taiwan Gender Equality Legislation and Case Studies. Beijing, falu chubanshe. (In Chinese)
Lu, Jie-feng. 2017. Examining the Exception of Gender Discrimination in Employment: American Experience and Lessons to China. Funu yanjiu luncong 2: 112–119. (In Chinese)
Ma, Yi-nan. 2009. Rethinking Women’s Forbidden Labour. Funu yanjiu luncong 2: 41–43. (In Chinese)
Podoplelova O. G. 2018. Gender stereotypes in the constitutional law of Russia: the trap of “special treatment”? Comparative constitutional review 3: 73–91. (In Russian)
Sinha Mukherjee, Sucharita. 2015. More educated and more equal? A comparative analysis of female education and employment in Japan, China and India. Gender and Education 27 (7): 846–870.
Stauffer B. 2018. “Only Men Need Apply”. Gender Discrimination in Job Advertisements in China. Available at: https://www.hrw.org/report/2018/04/23/only-men-need-apply/gender-discrimination-job-advertisements-china (accessed: 20.02.2020).
Sun, Yue. 2017. The Legal Issues in the Field of Employment Sex Discrimination. Fazhi bolan 15: 150–151. (In Chinese)
Sundstrom L., Sperling V., Sayoglu M. 2019. What Gender Discrimination? Psychological and Sociocultural Barriers. Courting gender justice: Russia, Turkey, and the European Court of Human Rights, ed. by L. Sundstrom. Oxford University Press: 30–68.
Varshavskaya, Elena Ya. 2006. Employment in the informal sector as a phenomenon of the modern Russian labour market. Bulletin of Kuzbass State Technical University 3: 123–128. Available at: https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/zanyatost-v-neformalnom-sektore-kak-fenomen-sovremennogo-rossiyskogo-rynka-truda (accessed: 07.08.2019). (In Russian)
Wang, Zheng. 2017. Finding women in the state: A socialist feminist revolution in the People’s Republic of China, 1949–1964. University of California Press.
Webster, Timothy, Ambivalence & Activism: Employment Discrimination in China (September 1, 2010). Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law, Vol.44, no. 643, 2011. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1670175 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1670175.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Articles of "Pravovedenie" are open access distributed under the terms of the License Agreement with Saint Petersburg State University, which permits to the authors unrestricted distribution and self-archiving free of charge.
