Political and Legal Views of Alexei Borovoy (Anarcho-humanism)

Authors

  • Andrey Sergeevich Bystrov National Research University “Higher School of Economics”

Abstract

The article discusses the political and legal views of Alexey Borovoy, a prominent Russian anarchist theoretician of the early 20th century. His philosophy, which represents an original system of views on social structure, is discussed in the context of the accepted classifications of the anarchist movements taking into account the historical and cultural development. The author describes the preconditions and genesis of Borovoy’s unique philosophy which demonstrates that his position, despite its closeness to the individualist anarchism, cannot be confined to a single scientific category. In his analysis of Borovoy’s views, the author gives a detailed review of Borovoy’s self-criticism of anarchism, mainly based on the opposition of prevailing contemporary anti-state theories. Borovoy applied this critical approach to representatives of the European and American individualist anarchism, in reconsidering Bakunin’s “seditious” theory and in his sceptical analysis of Kropotkin’s doctrine. Apart from the ideologies, the scientist hotly criticized the “state structure” and institutional political forms. Accordingly, the article focuses on the issue of parliamentary system as an institution which, according to Borovoy, instead of being a venue for competition of national or public interests, is limited to rival ambitions of few most active population groups. The article also considers the role and essence of the law within the system of Borovoy’s views. The author gives a detailed analysis of the anarchist theory developed by Borovoy, the evolution of his views and their connection with the key events and philosophic movements in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. The resulting conclusion is that Borovoy’s philosophy remains highly relevant and his theories on the state and the law are of great scientific importance. The anarchist theoretician has made a notable contribution to the legacy of political and legal thought.

Keywords:

anarchism, law, individualism, authority, state, revolution, personality, society

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Author Biography

Andrey Sergeevich Bystrov , National Research University “Higher School of Economics”

assistant, postgraduate student, Department of Theory and History of Law, Law Faculty

References

Aladyshkin I.V. Anarkho-individualizm v srede otechestvennoi intelligentsii vtoroi poloviny XIX — pervoi dekady XX veka (na materialakh gg. Moskva i Sankt-Peterburg). Dis. kand. urid. nauk [The Individualist Anarchism Among Russian Intellectuals in the Second Half of the 19th Century (based on Moscow and St. Petersburg materials). A thesis for a degree in law]. Ivanovo, 2006. 284 p. (in Russian)

Bel’kovich R.Yu. Anarkho-individualizm v politiko-pravovoi mysli SShA XIX — nachala XX veka. Dis. kand. urid. nauk [The Individualist Anarchism in the US Political and Legal Thought in the 19th — early 20th centuries: A thesis for a degree in law]. Moscow, 2009. 162 p. (in Russian)

Berdyaev N. A. Russkaia ideia [The Russian Idea]. St. Petersburg, Azbuka-klassika Publ., 2008. 320 p. (in Russian)

Borovoi A.A. Anarkhizm [Anarchism]. Moscow, Librokom Publ., 2011. 169 p. (in Russian)

Borovoi A. A. Vlast’. Anarkhiia i Vlast’ [Power. Anarchy and Power]. Moscow, Nauka Publ., 1992. 174 p. (in Russian)

Borovoi A. A. Lichnost’ i obshchestvo v anarkhistskom mirovozzrenii [Individual and Society in the Anarchist Worldview]. Petrograd, Moscow, Golos Truda Publ., 1920. 104 p. (in Russian)

Borovoi A.A. Mikhailu Bakuninu (1876–1926). Ocherki istorii anarkhicheskogo dvizheniia v Rossii: sb. statei [To Michael Bakunin (1876–1926): An Outline of the History of Anarchist Movement in Russia: Collection of Articles]. Moscow, Golos Truda Publ., 1926. 340 p. (in Russian)

Borovoi A. A. Moia zhizn’. Vospominaniia. Glava VII. Kak ia stal anarkhistom [My Life. Memoirs. Chapter VII. How I Became an Anarchist]. Chelovek, 2010, no.3, pp.137–153. (in Russian)

Borovoi A. A. Obshchestvennye idealy sovremennogo chelovechestva. Liberalizm. Sotsializm. Anarkhizm [Social Ideals of the Modern Humanity. Liberalism. Socialism. Anarchism]. Moscow, Ideya Publ., 1906. 94 p. (in Russian)

Borovoi A. A. [The Problems of Individual in Kropotkin’s Doctrine]. Petr Kropotkin: sb. st. [Petr Kropotkin. Collection of Articles]. Eds A.Borovoi, N.Lebedev. Petrograd, Golos Truda; Moscow, Golos Truda Publ., 1922. 250 p. (in Russian)

Borovoi A. A. Revoliutsionnoe mirosozertsanie [Revolutionary Worldview]. Moscow, Logos Publ., 1907. 86 p. (in Russian)

Borovoi A.A. Revoliutsionnoe tvorchestvo i parlament (revoliutsionnyi sindikalizm) [Revolutionary Creativity and Parliament (Revolutionary Syndicalism)]. 2nd ed. Moscow, Soyuz Truda Publ., 1917. 84 p. (in Russian)

Borovoi A.A., Otverzhenny N. Mif o Bakunine [The Bakunin Myth]. Petrograd, Moscow, Golos Truda Publ., 1925. 192 p. (in Russian)

Volodenkov S. V., Zverev A. L., Kuznetsov I. I., Setov N. R., Telin K. O. Predstavitel’naia demokratiia i parlamentskie uchrezhdeniia v sovremennom mire: sostoianie i tendentsii [The Future of Representative Democracy and Parliamentarian Institutions in the Modern World and in Russia]. Moscow, 2014. 128 p. (in Russian)

Mamut L. S. Etatizm i anarkhizm kak tipy politicheskogo soznaniia. Domarksistskii period [Statism and Anarchism as Types of Political Beliefs. The Pre-Marksist Period]. Moscow, Nauka Publ., 1989. 256 p. (in Russian)

Makhno N.I. Vospominaniia. Kniga II. Pod udarami kontrrevoliutsii [Memoirs. Book II. Under the Blows of the Counterrevolution]. Paris, 1936. 97 p. (in Russian)

Oleynikov D. I. Anarkho-gumanizm Alekseia Borovogo [The Anarcho-Humanism of A. Borovoi]. Obshchina, 1991, no. 49, pp. 4–6. (in Russian)

Rublev D. I., Ryabov P. V. Aleksei Alekseevich Borovoi: Chelovek, myslitel’, anarkhist [Alexei Borovoi: The Man, the Thinker, the Anarchist]. Rossiia i sovremennyi mir [Russia and the Modern World], 2011, no. 2, pp. 221–229. (in Russian)

Ryabov P.V. Aleksei Alekseevich Borovoi i Aleksandr Ivanovich Gertsen. Priamukhinskie chteniia 2012 [Alexei Borovoi and Alexander Herzen. Pryamukhino Readings 2012]. Moscow, Futuris Publ., 2013, pp. 170–191. (in Russian)

Ryabov P. V. Aleksei Borovoi i filosofiia Fridrikha Nitsshe (iz istorii russkogo nitssheanstva v nachale KhKh veka) [Alexei Borovoi and the Philosophy of Friedrich Nietzsche (From the History of Russian Nietzscheism in the Early 20th Century)]. Prepodavatel’ XXI vek, 2010, no. 2, ch. 2, pp. 217–225. (in Russian)

Ryabov P. V. Anarkhicheskaia filosofiia Alekseia Borovogo (iz istorii russkogo bergsonianstva) [The Anarchist Philosophy of Alexei Borovoi (From the History of Russian Bergsonism)]. Bulletin of the Immanuel Kant Baltic Federal University, 2010, no.6, pp. 24–23. (in Russian)

Ryabov P.V. “Byloe i dumy” Alekseia Borovogo [‘My Past and Thoughts’ of Alexei Borovoi]. Chelovek, 2010, no. 3, pp. 137–152. (in Russian)

Ryabov P.V. Muzyka v mirosozertsanii Borovogo. Priamukhinskie chteniia 2010 [Music in Borovoi’s Worldview, Pryamukhino Readings 2010]. Moscow, Futuris Publ., 2012, pp. 40–64. (in Russian)

Ryabov P.V. Problema lichnosti v filosofii klassicheskogo anarkhizma. Dis. kand. urid. nauk [The Problem of Individual in the Classical Anarchist Philosophy: a thesis for a degree in law]. Moscow, 1996. Available at: http://www.dissercat.com/content/problema-lichnosti-v-filosofii-klassicheskogo-anarkhizma (accessed: 15.05.2016). (in Russian)

Ryabov P.V. Romanticheskii anarkhizm Alekseia Borovogo (iz istorii russkoi filosofii zhizni) [The Romantic Anarchism of Alexei Borovoi (From the History of Russian Philosophy of Life)]. Istoriko-filosofskii ezhegodnik [History and Philosophy Yearbook 2011]. Moscow, IF RAN Publ., 2012, no. 1, pp. 416–435. (in Russian)

Ryabov P.V. Rossiiskoe kantianstvo i neokantianstvo nachala ХХ veka v neopublikovannykh memuarakh A. A. Borovogo [The Russian Kantianism and neo-Kantianism in the Early 20th Century from the Unpublished Memoirs of Alexey Borovoi]. Kantovskii sbornik [The Kantian Collection], 2010, no. 4, pp. 9–104. (in Russian)

Ryabov P. V. Filosofiia postklassicheskogo rossiiskogo anarkhizma — terra incognita [Philosophy of Postclassical Russian Anarchism — Terra Incognita]. Prepodavatel’ XXI Vek, 2009, no. 3, pp. 289–298. (in Russian)

Ryabov P.V. Khorosho zabytoe staroe: obzor arkhivnogo fonda A.A.Borovogo v RGALI [The Well-Forgotten Thoughts: Review of A. Borovoi’s Archives in the Russian State Archive of Literature and Art (RGALI)]. Kul’turologiia [Culturology], 2009, no.1, pp. 112–126. (in Russian)

Rousseau J.-J. Ob obshchestvennom dogovore. Traktaty [The Social Contract. Treatise]. Transl. from French. Moscow, KANON-press, Kuchkovo pole Publ., 1998. 416 p. (in Russian)

Rousseau J.-J. Pedagogicheskie sochineniia [Educational Works]. Ed. by G. N. Dzhibladze; comp. by A. N. Dzhurinsky. (Educational Library). Vol. 1. Moscow, Pedagogika Publ., 1981. 656 p. (in Russian)

Silaev N.Yu. Vozvrashchenie varvarstva [The Return of Barbarism]. Rossiia v global’noi politike [Russia in the Global Policy], 2014, no. 5, pp. 152–161. (in Russian)

Shubin A.V. Anarkhiia rabotaet [Anarchy Does Work]. Moscow, Common Place Publ., 2015. 190 p. (in Russian)

Udartsev S.F. Politicheskaia i pravovaia teoriia anarkhizma v Rossii: istoriia i sovremennost’. Dis. doct. urid. nauk [Political and Legal Theory of Anarchism in Russia: History and the Present State. A doctorate thesis for a degree in law]. Moscow, 1992. 498 p. (in Russian)

Published

01.12.2016

How to Cite

Bystrov , A. S. (2016). Political and Legal Views of Alexei Borovoy (Anarcho-humanism). Pravovedenie, 60(6), 184–211. Retrieved from https://pravovedenie.spbu.ru/article/view/7036

Issue

Section

History of the legal thought