Defense of “Strict Petrażyckianism”
Abstract
In Human rights in the context of a Petrażyckian perspective Prof. Polyakov criticized Fittipaldi’s “Strict Petrażyckianism”. Here Fittipaldi replies to Polyakov’s critiques. Fittipaldi argues that scientific concepts select classes of phenomena able to enter as causes into nomological hypotheses. Law, stipulatively defined as a particular class of psychical phenomena (psylaw)—namely, as perceptions/representations of actions coupled imperative-attributive emotions (a concept close to sense of entitlement)—is the proximate cause of conflicts and, in turn, of unifying tendencies somewhat counteracting them (positivization, formalizations, adjudication). Further, psylaw causes the emergence of soclaw, understood as a gradual phenomenon whose degrees of existence increase with the degree of compatibility of the jural phenomena (psylaw) occurring in a given society. If psylaw is the distal cause of phenomena like states or market economies, soclaw can be regarded as their proximal cause, and so can be regarded as a scientific concept in its own right. In the remaining parts of this essay Fittipaldi defends the distinction between of intuitive and positive psylaw, and underscores the need both of legal dogmatics (understood as including deontic logic) and of sharply distinguishing it from psylaw and soclaw, thus implying that strict Petrażyckianism is incompatible with integral concepts of law.
Keywords:
Leon Petrażycki, Andrey V. Polyakov, scientific conceptualization, strict petrażyckianism, intuitive law, positive law, legal dogmatics, deontic logic
Downloads
Download data is not yet available.
References
Albert, Hans, 1987. Kritik der reinen Erkenntnislehre. Tübingen, J. C. B. Mohr (Paul Siebeck), 183 s.
Albert, Hans, 1991. Traktat über kritische Vernunft. Tübingen: J.C.B.Mohr (Paul Siebeck), 284 s.
Berger, Thomas, & Peter L. Luckman, 1971 [1966]. The Social Construction of Reality. London: Penguin, 249 p.
Bohnen, Alfred, 1975. Individualismus und Gesellschaftstheorie. Tübingen: J. C. B. Mohr (Paul Siebeck), 94 s.
Коммуникативная теория права и современные проблемы юриспруденции: к 60-летию Андрея Васильевича Полякова. Коллективная монография: в 2 т. Т.1. Коммуникативная теория права в исследованиях отечественных и зарубежных ученых / под ред. М. В. Антонова, И. Л. Честнова; предисл. Д. И. Луковской, Е. В. Тимошиной. СПб.: ООО Издательский дом «Алеф-Пресс», 2014. (Kommunikativnaia teoriia prava i sovremennye problemy iurisprudentsii: k 60-letiiu Andreia Vasil’evicha Poliakova. Kollektivnaia monografiia: v 2 t. T.1. Kommunikativnaia teoriia prava v issledovaniiakh otechestvennykh i zarubezhnykh uchenykh/ pod red. M.V.Antonova, I.L.Chestnova; predisl. D. I. Lukovskoi, E. V. Timoshinoi. SPb.: OOO Izdatel’skii dom «Alef-Press», 2014.)
Communicative Theory of Law and Contemporary Problems of Law: the 60th Anniversary of Andrei Vasilievich Polyakov. Collective monograph: in 2 v. V.1. The Communicative Theory of Law in Domestic and Foreign Research Scientists / ed. by M. V. Antonov, I. L. Chestnov; foreword by D. I. Lukovskaya, E. V. Timoshina. SPb.: Publishing House Ltd. “Alef-Press”, 2014.
Cotterrell, Roger, 2015. Leon Petrażycki and contemporary socio-legal studies. International Journal of Law in Context, 11, 1: 1–16.
Czepita, Stanisław, 1980. Koncepcje teoretycznoprawne w Polsce międzywojennej. Czasopismo Prawno-Historiczne, 32, 2: 107–149.
De Waal, Frans, 1996. Good natured: The origins of right and wrong in humans and other animals. Cambridge (MA) & London: Harvard University Press, pp. 296.
De Waal, Frans, 1998. Chimpanzee politics. Power and sex among apes. The Johns Hopkins University Press: Baltimore & London, pp. 235.
Ferrari, Vincenzo, 2005. Diritto e società. Elementi di sociologia del diritto. Roma-Bari: Laterza, pp. 222.
Fittipaldi, Edoardo, 2009. Bonae fidei possessor fructus consumptos suos facit. Tentative Answers to One Question Left Open by Petrażycki’s Economic Analysis of Law. Societas/Communitas 1: 15–35.
Fittipaldi, Edoardo, 2012. Everyday Legal Ontology. A Psychological and Linguistic Investigation within the Framework of Leon Petrazycki’s Theory of Law. Milan: Led, pp. 302.
Fittipaldi, Edoardo, 2013a. Conoscenza giuridica ed errore: Saggio sullo statuto epistemologico degli asserti prodotti dalla dogmatica giuridica. Rome: Aracne, pp. 144.
Fittipaldi, Edoardo, 2013b. Nauka na službe principa u zakonnosti: kritičeskaja zaščita koncepcii juridičeskoj dogmatiki L’va Petražickogo. Pravovedenie, 5: 48–76.
Fittipaldi, Edoardo, 2014. Psihosociologija prav čeloveka: dve petražickianskie perspectivy (Psychosociology of human rights: Two Petrażyckian perspectives). Pravovedenie, 5: 8–30. Also published in Коммуникативная теория права и современные проблемы юриспруденции: к 60-летию Андрея Васильевича Полякова. Коллективная монография: в 2 т. Т. 1. Коммуникативная теория права в исследованиях отечественных и зарубежных ученых / под ред. М. В. Антонова, И. Л. Честнова; предисл. Д. И. Луковской, Е. В. Тимошиной. СПб.: ООО Издательский дом «Алеф-Пресс», 2014. (Kommunikativnaia teoriia prava i sovremennye problemy iurisprudentsii: k 60-letiiu Andreia Vasil’evicha Poliakova. Kollektivnaia monografiia: v 2 t. T.1. Kommunikativnaia teoriia prava v issledovaniiakh otechestvennykh i zarubezhnykh uchenykh / pod red. M. V. Antonova, I. L. Chestnova; predisl. D. I. Lukovskoi, E. V. Timoshinoi. SPb.: OOO Izdatel’skii dom «Alef-Press», 2014.)
Fittipaldi, Edoardo, 2015a. Contradictions as Empirical Incompatibilities. Bridging Psychology of Ethical Emotions with Normative Dogmatics. In Stefano Colloca & Paolo Di Lucia (eds.). L’impossibilità normative: 165–178.
Фиттипальди, Эдоардо, 2014. Психосоциология прав человека: две петражицкианские перспективы. Правоведение. No 5. С. 8–30. (Fittipal’di, Edoardo, 2014. Psikhologiia prav cheloveka: dve petrazhitskianskie perspektivy. Pravovedenie. No 5. S. 8–30.)
Фиттипальди, Эдоардо, 2015b. Противоречия как эмпирические несовместимости в психологии этических эмоций и в правовой (и не только) догматике: радикально-эмпирический подход. Правоведение. 2015. No 5. С. 24–40. (Fittipal’di, Edoardo, 2015b. Protivorechiia kak empiricheskie nesovmestimosti v psikhologii eticheskikh emotsii i v pravovoi (i ne tol’ko) dogmatike: radikal’no-empiricheskii podkhod. Pravovedenie. 2015. No 5. S. 24–40.)
Fittipaldi, Edoardo, 2015b. Controversy as Empirical Incompatibility in Psychology and Ethics of Emotions in the Legal (and not only) Dogma: a Radically Empirical Approach. Proceedings of the Higher Educational Institutions. Jurisprudence. 2015. No 5. P. 24–40.
Fittipaldi, Edoardo, 2015c. Jural Emotions, Anger, Aggressiveness: Cross-Fertilizing Petrażycki’s Theory of Law with Modern Theories of Emotions. Paper delivered at the XXVII World Congress of the International Association for the Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy (IVR). Washington, DC, July 27–August 1, 2015. Available (under the title Jural Emotions, Anger, Aggressiveness: Examples of Cross-Fertilization of Petrażycki’s Theory of Right with Modern Psychology, Psychiatry and Criminology) at http://unimi.academia.edu/EdoardoFittipaldi (retrieved February 16, 2016).
Fittipaldi, Edoardo, 2015d. Love, anankasticity, and human rights: The perspective of a Petrażyckian continental legal realism. In Piotr Szymaniec (ed.), The principle of proportionality and the protection of the fundamental rights in the European states. Wałbrzych: Wydawnictwo Państwowej Wyższej Szkoły Zawodowej im. Angelusa Silesiusa w Wałbrzychu.
Fittipaldi, Edoardo, 2016a. Leon Petrażycki. In Enrico Pattaro & Corrado Roversi (eds.), Legal Philosophy in the Twentieth Century: The Civil Law World. In Vol. 12, Tome 2, of Enrico Pattaro (ed.), A Treatise of Legal Philosophy and General Jurisprudence. Berlin, etc.: Springer.
Fittipaldi, Edoardo, 2016b. Continental Legal Realism. In Enrico Pattaro & Corrado Roversi (eds.), Legal Philosophy in the Twentieth Century: The Civil Law World. In Vol. 12, Tome 2, of Enrico Pattaro (ed.), A Treatise of Legal Philosophy and General Jurisprudence. Berlin, etc.: Springer.
Fittipaldi, Edoardo, 2016c. Jerzy Lande. In Enrico Pattaro & Corrado Roversi (eds.), Legal Philosophy in the Twentieth Century: The Civil Law World. In Vol.12, Tome 2, of Enrico Pattaro (ed.), A Treatise of Legal Philosophy and General Jurisprudence. Berlin, etc.: Springer.
Fittipaldi, Edoardo, & Elena V.Timoshina, 2017. Theory of Custom, Dogmatics of Custom, Policy of Custom: On the Threefold Approach of Polish-Russian Legal Realism. Ratio Juris. Vol. 30, no. 1. March 2017. P. 105–122.
Durkheim, Émile, 1897. Le Suicide: Étude de sociologie. Paris: Félix Alcan, 462 p.
Faiella, Matteo, 2016. Dogmatica giuridica e scienze formali. Una comparazione strutturale. Tesi di laurea, Università degli Studi di Milano, pp. 90.
Freud, Sigmund, 1953/1974[1921]. Massenpsychologie und Ich-Analyse. English translation Group Psychology and the Analysis of the Ego. In Sigmund Freud (James Strachey ed.), Standard edition of the complete psychological works of Sigmund Freud, vol. 18: 67–143.
Galtung, Johan, 1959. Expectations and interaction processes. Inquiry, 2: 213–234.
Geiger, Theodor, 1964. Vostudien zu einer soziologie des Rechts. Neuwied am Rhein & Berlin: Lucheterhand, pp. 471.
Hayek, Friedrich. A. von., 1952. The Counter-Revolution of Science: Studies on the Abuse of Reason. Indianapolis: Liberty Fund Inc., pp. 415.
Hayek, Friedrich. A. von., 1973–1979. Law, Legislation and Liberty: A New Statement of the Liberal Principles of Justice and Political Economy. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
Heshka, Stanley, & Yona Nelson, 1972. Interpersonal Speaking Distance as a Function of Age, Sex, and Relationship. Sociometry, 35, 4: 491–498.
Kurczewski, Jacek, 1976. Due dimensioni del diritto: diritto positivo o intuitive e diritto ufficiale e non ufficiale. Sociologia del diritto, 3, 1: 29–49.
Kurczewski, Jacek, 1977. O badaniu prawa w naukach społecznych. Warsaw: Wydawnictwo Universytetu Warszawskiego, pp. 169.
Lakatos, Imre, 1978[1976]. Proofs and Refutations: The Logic of Mathematical Discovery. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 188.
Lakatos, Imre (John Worrall & Gregory Currie (eds.)), 1980. Mathematics, Science and Epistemology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 285.
Lande, Jerzy, 1925. Norma a zjawisko prawne: Rozważania nad podstawami teorii prawa na tle krytyki systemu Kelsena. In Prace z dziedziny teorji prawa. Ed. W. L. Jaworski, 235–348. Cracow: Krakowska spółka wydawnicza.
Lande, Jerzy, 1926. Logika a pośpiech w teorii prawa. Odpowiedź na replikę P. Cz. Znamierowskiego (“Czasopismo prawn. i. ek.” R. XXIII, Nr. 1–12, str. 190–416). Czasopismo prawnicze i ekonomiczne, 26, 1–12: 361–396.
Lande, Jerzy, 1935. O tak zwanej socjologji nauki. Special extract from the tome XXX of Czasopismo prawnicze. Cracow: Drukarnia Uniwersytetu Jagiellieńskiego pod zarządem J. Filipowskiego.
Lande, Jerzy, 1947. W sprawie polityki językowej. Osobne odbicie z “Języka polskiego”, v. 27, n. 2: 33–38.
Lande, Jerzy, 1959[1929–30]. Historia filozofii prawa. In Jerzy Lande (Kasimierz Opałek ed.), Studia z filozofii prawa. Warsaw: PWN, 405–557.
Lande, Jerzy, 1959[1932]. Leon Petrażycki. In Jerzy Lande (Kasimierz Opałek ed.), Studia z filozofii prawa. Warsaw: PWN, pp. 561–616.
Lande, Jerzy, 1959[1933]. Sprawa teorii prawa. In Jerzy Lande (Kasimierz Opałek ed.), Studia z filozofii prawa. Warsaw: PWN, pp. 619–683.
Lande, Jerzy, 1959[1948]. O ocenach. Uwagi dyskusyjne. In Jerzy Lande (Kasimierz Opałek ed.), Studia z filozofii prawa. Warsaw: PWN: 731–839.
Luhmann, Niklas, 1969. Normen in soziologischer Perspektive. Soziale Welt, 20, 1: 28–48.
Merezhko, Oleksandr [Aleksandr], 2012. Psihologičeskaja teorija prava mežduradnogo prava (publičnogo i častnogo). Odessa: Feniks, p. 242.
Мережко, Олександр, 2012. Психологическая теория международного права (публичного и частного). Одесса: Феникс, 244 с. (Merezhko, Oleksandr, 2012. Psikhologicheskaia teoriia mezhdunarodnogo prava (publichnogo i chastnogo). Odessa: Feniks, 244 s.)
Merezhko, Oleksandr, 2012. Psychological Theory of International Law (public and private). Odessa: Phoenix 244.
Merezhko, Oleksandr, 2013. International Commercial Arbitration from the Perspective of the Psychological Theory of Law. Arbitration e-Review, special issue.
Merton, Robert K., 1968. Social Theory and Social Structure. New York: The Free Press, pp. 702.
Motyka, Krzysztof, 1993. Wpływ Leona Petrażyckiego na polską teorię i socjologię prawa. Lublin: Redakcja wydawnictw katolickiego uniwersytetu Lubelskiego, pp. 230.
Motyka, Krzysztof, 2007. Leon Petrażycki challenge to legal orthodoxy. Lublin: Towarzystwo Naukowe Katolickiego Universytetu Ludelskiego Jana Pawła II, pp. 55.
Olivecrona, Karl, 1971. Law as Fact. London: Stevens & Sons, pp. 317.
Ossowski, Jerzy, 1935a. O predmocie socjologji. Prace socjologiczne, 1: 37–40 (ed. by Koło Socjologizne S. U. W. im L. Petrażyckiego, Warsaw: Hösick).
Ossowski, Jerzy, 1935b. Teorja przystosowania i doboru społecznego. Prace socjologiczne, 1: 41–46 (ed. by Koło Socjologizne S.U.W.im L.Petrażyckiego, Warsaw: Hösick)
Ossowski, Jerzy, 1935c. Ważniejsze wytwory przystosowania i doboru społecznego: prawo, moralność i religja. Prace socjologiczne, 1: 47–58 (ed. by Koło Socjologizne S. U. W. im L. Petrażyckiego, Warsaw: Hösick).
Pattaro, Enrico, 2005. The Law and the Right. A Reapprisal of the Reality that Ought to Be. Berlin, etc.: Springer, pp. 457.
Pattaro, Enrico, 2016. Axel Hägerström at the Origins of the Uppsala School. In Enrico Pattaro & Corrado Roversi (eds.), Legal Philosophy in the Twentieth Century: The Civil Law World. In Vol. 12, Tome 2, of Enrico Pattaro (ed.), A Treatise of Legal Philosophy and General Jurisprudence. Berlin, etc.: Springer.
Паттаро Э. Действительность, нормы как верования и их эффективность. Правоведение. 2015. No 6. (Pattaro E. Deistvitel‘nost‘, tip i znak, norma, verovanie, effektivnost‘. Pravovedenie. 2015. No 6.)
Petrażycki, Leon. 1895. Die Lehre von Einkommen. Vol. 2. Berlin: Müller, pp. 628.
Петражицкий, Лев, 1901. Право и суд. Право: 1–6, 2: 117–126, 311–320. (Petrazhitskii, Lev, 1901. Pravo i sud. Pravo: 1–6, 2: 117–126, 311–320.)
Petrażycki, Leon. 1901. The Law and the Court. Law: 1–6, 2: 117–126, 311–320.
Петражицкий, Лев, 1902. К вопросу о “возрождении естественного права” и нашей программе. По поводу диссертации П. И. Новгородцева “Кант и Гегель в их учениях о праве и государстве”. Два типических построения в области философии права. Право, 41, 42, 43. (Petrazhitskii, Lev, 1902. K voprosu o “vozrozhdenii estestvennogo prava” i nashei programme. Po povodu dissertatsii P.I.Novgorodtseva “Kant i Gegel’ v ikh ucheniiakh o prave i gosudarstve”. Dva tipicheskikh postroeniia v oblasti filosofii prava. Pravo, 41, 42, 43.)
Petrażycki, Leon. 1902. On the Question of “the Revival of Natural Law” and our Program. Regarding the Thesis of P. I. Novgorodtseva “Kant and Hegel in their Teachings about the Law and the State”. Two Typical of Construction in the Area of Philosophy of Law. Law, 41, 42, 43.
Петражицкий, Лев, 1908. Введение в изучение права и нравственности. Основы эмоциональной психологии. Санкт-Петербург: Эрлих. (Petrazhitskii, Lev, 1908. Vvedenie v izuchenie prava i nravstvennosti. Osnovy emotsional’noi psikhologii. Sankt-Peterburg: Erlikh.)
Petrażycki, Leon. 1908. Introduction to the Study of Law and Morality. Fundamentals of Emotional Psychology. St. Petersburg: Ehrlich.
Петражицкий, Лев, 1909–10. Теория права и государства в связи с теорией нравственности. 2-е изд. Санкт-Петербург: Екатерингофское Печатное Дело. (Petrazhitskii, Lev, 1909–10. Teoriia prava i gosudarstva v sviazi s teoriei nravstvennosti. 2-e izd. Sankt-Peterburg: Ekateringofskoe Pechatnoe Delo.)
Petrażycki, Leon. 1909–10. Theory of Law and State in the Connection with the Theory of Morality. 2nd ed. St. Petersburg: Ekateringofsky printing.
Петражицкий, Лев, 1911. Акции, биржевая игра и теория экономических кризисов (Stocks, speculation, and a theory of economic crises). Санкт-Петербург: Типография M.Mеркушева, 307 с. (Petrazhitskii, Lev, 1911. Aktsii, birzhevaia igra i teoriia ekonomicheskikh krizisov (Stocks, speculation, and a theory of economic crises). Sankt-Peterburg: Tipografiia M. Merkusheva, 307 p.)
Petrażycki, Leon. 1911. The Stocks, Speculation and the Theory of Economic Crisis. St. Petersburg: Typography of M. Merkusheva, 307 p.
Petrażycki, Leon (Jerzy Finkelkraut [J.Licki] ed.), 1939a. Nowe podstawy logiki i klasyficacja umiejętności. Warsaw: Towarzystwo im. Leona Petrażyckiego, pp. 115.
Petrażycki, Leon, 1939b. Szkice Filozoficzne. O tak zwanej metodzie krytycznej oraz o metafizyce i filozofii praktycznej Kanta. Warsaw: Nakładem Towarzystwa im. Leona Petrażyckiego.
Петражицкий, Лев, 2002[1902]. Права добросовестного владельца на доходы с точки зрения догмы и политики гражданского права (The bona fide possessor’s right to incomes from the point of view of the dogma and policy of private law). (Petrazhitskii, Lev, 2002[1902]. Prava dobrosovestnogo vladel’tsa na dokhody s tochki zreniia dogmy i politiki grazhdanskogo prava (The bona fide possessor’s right to incomes from the point of view of the dogma and policy of private law).)
Petrażycki, Leon, The Bona Fide Possessor’s Right to Incomes from the point of view of the Dogma and Policy of Private Law.
Петражицкий, Лев, 2010[1896–97]. Введение в науку политики права. В: Лев Петражицкий (ред. Е.В.Тимошина). Теория и политика права. Избранные труды. Санкт-Петербург: Университетский Издательский консорциум: 3–184. (Petrazhitskii, Lev, 2010[1896–97]. Vvedenie v nauku politiki prava. V: Lev Petrazhitskii (red. E. V. Timoshina). Teoriia i politika prava. Izbrannye Trudy. Sankt-Peterburg: Universitetskii Izdatel’skii konsortsium: 3–184.)
Petrażycki, Leon, 2010 [1896–97]. Introduction to the Science of Law Policy. In: Leon Petrażycki (ed. E. Timoshina). Theory and Policy of Law. Selected works. St. Petersburg: University Publishing Consortium: 3–184.
Петражицкий, Лев. 2010[1908]. Введение в изучение права и нравственности. Основы эмоциональной психологии. В: Лев Петражицкий (ред. Е.В.Тимошина). Теория и политика права. Избранные труды. Санкт-Петербург: Университетский Издательский консорциум: 380–560. (Petrazhitskii, Lev. 2010[1908]. Vvedenie v izuchenie prava i nravstvennosti. Osnovy emotsional’noi psikhologii. V: Lev Petrazhitskii (red. E. V. Timoshina). Teoriia i politika prava. Izbrannye Trudy. Sankt-Peterburg: Universitetskii Izdatel’skii konsortsium: 380-560.)
Petrażycki, Leon, 2010 [1908]. Introduction to the Study of Law and Morality. Fundamentals of Emotional Psychology. In: Leon Petrażycki (ed. E. Timoshina). Theory and Policy of Law. Selected works. St. Petersburg: University Publishing Consortium: 380–560.
Петражицкий, Лев, 2010[1913]. К вопросу о социальном идеале и возрождении естественного права. В: Лев Петражицкий (ред. Е.В.Тимошина). Теория и политика права. Избранные труды. Санкт-Петербург: Университетский Издательский консорциум: 561–598. (Petrazhitskii, Lev, 2010[1913]. K voprosu o sotsial’nom ideale i vozrozhdenii estestvennogo prava. V: Lev Petrazhitskii (red. E.V.Timoshina). Teoriia i politika prava. Izbrannye Trudy. Sankt-Peterburg: Universitetskii Izdatel’skii konsortsium: 561–598.)
Petrażycki, Leon, 2010 [1913]. On the Question of the Social Ideal and the Revival of Natural Law. In: Leon Petrażycki (ed. E. Timoshina). Theory and Policy of Law. Selected works. St. Petersburg: University Publishing Consortium: 561–598.
Petrażycki, Leon, 2010[1939a]. Nowe podstawy logiki i klasyfikacja umiejętności. Перевод на русский: Новые основания логики и классификация наук. В: Лев Петражицкий (ред. Е.В.Тимошина). Теория и политика права. Избранные труды. Санкт- Петербург: Университетский Издательский консорциум: 775–856. (Novye osnovaniia logiki i klassifikatsiia nauk. V: Lev Petrazhitskii (red. E. V. Timoshina). Teoriia i politika prava. Izbrannye Trudy. Sankt-Peterburg: Universitetskii Izdatel’skii konsortsium: 775–856.)
Petrażycki, Leon, 2010[1939b]. Szkice Filozoficzne. O tak zwanej metodzie krytycznej oraz o metafizyce i filozofii praktycznej Kanta. Russian translation Filosofskie očerki. O tak nazyvaemom kritičeskom metode i o metafizike i praktičeskoj filosofii Kanta. In: Leon Petrażycki (Elena V. Timoshina ed.), Teoriia i politika prava. Izbrannye Trudy. Saint Petersburg: Universitetskij Izdatel’skij konsorcium: 601–774.
Piaget, Jean 1973 [1926]. La représentation du monde chez l’enfant. English translation: The child’s conception of the world. London: Paladin, pp. 444.
Поляков, А. В. 2016a. Права человека в контексте «петражицкианской перспективы». Правоведение. No 1. 2016. С.46–61. (Poliakov A.V. 2016a. Prava cheloveka v kontekste «petrazhitskianskoi perspektivy». Pravovedenie. No 1. 2016. S. 46–61.)
Polyakov, A. V. 2016a. Human Rights in the Context of “Petrazhitskian Perspective” Jurisprudence. No 1. 2016. p. 46–61.
Поляков, А.В. 2016b. Общая теория права. Проблемы интерпретации в контексте коммуникативного подхода. Москва: Проспект. 832 с. (Poliakov A.V. 2016b. Obshchaia teoriia prava. Problemy interpretatsii v kontekste kommunikativnogo podkhoda. Moskva: Prospekt. 832 s.)
Polyakov, A.V. 2016b. General Theory of Law. Problems of Interpretation in the Context of the Communicative Approach. Moscow: Prospect. 832 p.
Popper, Karl, 1994[1945]. The Open Society and Its Enemies. London: Routledge, pp. 808.
Postema, Gerald J., 2011. Legal Philosophy in the Twentieth Century: The Common Law World. In Vol. 11 of Enrico Pattaro (ed.), A Treatise of Legal Philosophy and General Jurisprudence. Berlin, etc.: Springer, pp. XXV+618.
Priest, George L., 1977. The Common Law Process and the Selection of Efficient Rules. Journal of Legal Studies, 6, 1: 65–82.
Ranulf, Svend, 1938. Moral Indignation and Middle Class Psychology: A Sociological Study. Copenhagen: Levin & Munksgaard, p. 204.
Rudolf von Rohr, Claudia, Judith M. Burkart, Carel P. van Schaik, 2011. Evolutionary precursors of social norms in chimpanzees: a new approach. Biology & Philosophy, 26: 1–30.
Тимошина, Е.В., 2011. Концепция нормативности Л.И.Петражицкого и проблема действительности права в юридическом позитивизме XX века. Правоведение. No 5. С.46–71. (Timoshina, E.V., 2011. Kontseptsiia normativnosti L.I.Petrazhitskogo i problema deistvitel’nosti prava v iuridicheskom pozitivizme XX veka. Pravovedenie. No 5. S. 46–71.)
Тимошина, Е. В., 2012. Как возможна теория права? Эпистемологические основания теории права в интерпретации Л. И. Петражицкого. Москва: Юрлитинформ. (Timoshina, E.V., 2012. Kak vozmozhna teoriia prava? Epistemologicheskie osnovaniia teorii prava v interpretatsii L. I. Petrazhitskogo. Moskva: Iurlitinform.)
Timoshina, E. V., 2012. How can the Theory of Law be? Epistemological Foundations of the Theory of Lof aw in the interpretation L. I. Petrazhitskiy. Moscow: Yuristinform.
Тимошина, Е. В., 2013. Л. И. Петражицкий vs. Е. Эрлих: Два проекта социологии права. Правоведение. No 5. С. 77–96. (Timoshina, E. V., 2013. L. I. Petrazhitskii vs. E. Erlikh: Dva proekta sotsiologii prava. Pravovedenie. N 5. S. 77–96.)
Timoshina, E.V., 2013. L.I.Petrazhitsky vs. E.Erlih: Two Projects of the Sociology of Law. Proceedings of the higher educational institution. Jurisprudence. Number 5. P. 77–96.
Тимошина, Е. В., 2014. Психологический реализм: M. Я. Лазерсон. Правоведение. No 5. С. 245–264. (Timoshina, E. V., 2014. Psikhologicheskii realizm: M. Ia. Lazerson. Pravovedenie. No 5. S. 245–264.)
Timoshina, E.V., 2014. Psychological realism: M.Ya. Lazerson. Jurisprudence. Number 5. P. 245–264.
Timoshina, E. V., 2016. Max Lazerson. In Enrico Pattaro & Corrado Roversi (eds.), Legal Philosophy in the Twentieth Century: The Civil Law World. In Vol.12, Tome 2, of Enrico Pattaro (ed.), A Treatise of Legal Philosophy and General Jurisprudence. Berlin, etc.: Springer.
Weber, Max (Guenther Roth and Claus Wittich eds.), 1968[1921/1964]. Wirtschaft und Gesellschaft. Grundriss der verstehenden Soziologie. English translation by Ephraim Fishhoff et al. Economy and Society. An outline of interpretive sociology. Berkeley, Los Angeles, and London: University of California Press, p. 1469.
Weber, Max (Johannes Winckelmann ed.), 1980[1921/1971]. Wirtschaft und Gesellschaft. Grundriß der verstehenden Soziologie. Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck.
Weber, Max, 1985[1917]. Der Sinn der “Wertfreiheit” der soziologischen und ökonomischen Wissenschaften. In Max Weber (Johannes Winckelmann ed.), Gesammelte Aufsätze zur Wissenschaftslehre. Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, available at http://www.zeno.org/Soziologie/M/Weber,+Max/Schriften+zur+Wissenschaftslehre/Der+Sinn+der+%C2%BBWertfreiheit%C2%AB+der+soziologischen+und+%C3%B6konomischen+Wissenschaften.
Downloads
Published
01.12.2016
How to Cite
Fittipaldi, E. ., & Osvetimskaya, I. I. (2016). Defense of “Strict Petrażyckianism”. Pravovedenie, 60(6), 6–73. Retrieved from https://pravovedenie.spbu.ru/article/view/7028
Issue
Section
Concept of law
License
Articles of "Pravovedenie" are open access distributed under the terms of the License Agreement with Saint Petersburg State University, which permits to the authors unrestricted distribution and self-archiving free of charge.
