Jurisdictional immunity of states and the judgement of the international court of justice in the case Germany vs. Italy, 2012

Authors

  • Igor S. Marusin Saint Petersburg State University

Abstract

The article analyzes the problem of jurisdictional immunity of states which was considered by the International Court of Justice in 2012 in the case Germany vs. Italy. This case is based on the examination by the Italian courts of a number of claims for compensation of damage which was caused by the German armed forces during the Second World War. As a general rule, foreign states enjoy immunity before foreign courts. However, in 2004 one of the highest Italian courts ruled that such immunity shall not be applied to the state which committed an international crime. The Government of Germany appealed against this judgement to the International Court of Justice, requesting that such actions of the Italian courts be classified as a violation of Italy’s international obligations. The article considers arguments put forward by the parties to support their positions, their assessment by the International Court of Justice, as well as the judgement itself which was in the favor of Germany. The author also points out that an absolute jurisdictional immunity of the state contradicts modern ideas about justice because it prevents many victims of armed conflicts from receiving compensation. As a way to resolve this contradiction, the author recommends the soonest entry into force of the UN Convention on Jurisdictional Immunities of States and Their Property of 2004 and application of its provisions to armed conflicts. 

Keywords:

international law, International Court of Justice, jurisdictional immunity, international responsibility, international crimes

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Author Biography

Igor S. Marusin, Saint Petersburg State University

doctor of legal sciences, professor of the Department of International Law

References

Getman-Pavlova I.V. Mezhdunarodnoe chastnoe pravo: uchebnik dlia magistrov [International private law]. Moscow, Yurait. 2015. 959 p. (In Russian)

Khlestova I.O. Iurisdiktsionnyi immunitet gosudarstva [Jurisdictional immunity of the state]. Moscow, Jurisprudence Publ., 2007. 214 p. (In Russian)

Mezhdunarodnoe chastnoe pravo: uchebnik dlia bakalavrov [International private law]. Ed. by G. K. Dmitrieva. Moscow, Prospekt Publ., 2015. 656 p. (In Russian)

Seleznyova N. A., Starzev D. D. Iurisdiktsionnye immunitety gosudarstva i ego sobstvennosti v grazhdanskom sudoproizvodstve Rossii, SShA i Velikobritanii [Jurisdictional immunities of the state in the legal procedure of Russia, USA and Great Britain]. Evraziiskii iuridicheskii zhurnal [Eurasian legal journal], 2015, no. 6, pp. 122–125. (In Russian)

Ushakov N.A. Iurisdiktsionnye immunitety gosudarstv i ikh sobstvennosti [Jurisdictional immunities of the states and their property]. Moscow, Nauka Publ., 1993. 240 p. (In Russian)

Vylegzhanin A.N., Churilina N.A. Mezhdunarodno-pravovye osnovaniia iurisdiktsionnogo immuniteta gosudarstv [Foundations of the jurisdictional immunity of the state in international law]. Moskovskii zhurnal mezhdunarodnogo prava [Moscow journal of international law], 2015, no. 2, pp. 35–51. (In Russian)

Yerpyleva N.Yu. Mezhdunarodnoe chastnoe pravo: uchebnik dlia bakalavrov [International private law]. Moscow, Yurait Publ., 2012. 1308 p. (In Russian)

Published

01.08.2016

How to Cite

Marusin, I. S. . (2016). Jurisdictional immunity of states and the judgement of the international court of justice in the case Germany vs. Italy, 2012. Pravovedenie, 60(4), 107–119. Retrieved from https://pravovedenie.spbu.ru/article/view/6993

Issue

Section

Public law