Theory and practice of legal regulation labor incapable employees
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.21638/spbu25.2018.303Abstract
The study of the legal personality of citizens recognized as legally incompetent by the court is timely and relevant in the light of the recent changes in the civil legislation of the Russian Federation, as well as the emerging trends in the development of judicial practice. In the doctrine of labor law, the legal personality of individuals is observed as an independent category of labor law, differing in this capacity from other related legal categories, in particular from civil legal capacity and legal capacity. At the same time, the labor legislation of the Russian Federation has made an unsuccessful attempt to receive the norms of civil legislation in relation to the employer — an individual who is recognized incapable by the court. At the moment, the Russian legislator with regard to the possibility of concluding an employment contract on the part of an employee recognized as legally incompetent took the position of “qualified silence”, which today can hardly be called successful for a number of reasons indicated in the proposed study. The study of the legal personality of citizens recognized as incapable makes it possible to assess the level of compliance of Russian legislation with international social and labor standards, determine the vectors for its further development and improvement in terms of optimal protection of human rights and citizenship. The main methods of the research were system and complex analysis of regulatory legal acts of the Russian Federation and a number of other countries and international organizations; Comparative method, which made it possible to compare the international regulation of the participation of incompetent citizens in the work activity with Russian labor legislation, as well as the labor legislation of certain countries of the near and far abroad; Method of expert assessment, based on the analysis of court decisions and scientific publications on the participation of incapacitated persons in labor relations. The results of the study are both theoretical and practical, and suggest some directions for improving the labor legislation of the Russian Federation on the participation in labor relations of citizens recognized by the court as legally incompetent.
Keywords:
subjects of labor law, labor legal personality, labor legal capacity, incompetent citizen differentiation, discrimination, representation in individual labor relations
Downloads
References
Baranova, Iuliia. 2017. The role of standards in ensuring the quality of legal services for the public. Baikal Research Journal, vol. 8, no. 3. https://doi.org/10.17150/2411-6262.2017.8(3).14 (In Russian)
Aleksandrov, Nikolay. 1948. Legal Relations. Moscow, Yuridicheskoe izdatelstvo Ministerstva Yustitsii SSSR Publ. 337 p. (In Russian)
Arkhipova, Olga, and Luzyanin, Taras. 2016. On the application of civil law in the regulation of labor relations. Vestnik Tomskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Pravo 4 (22): 107–119. https:// doi.org/10.17223/22253513/22/12 (In Russian)
Arkhipov, Sergey. 2004. Subject of law: theoretical study. St. Petersburg, Yuridicheskiy tsentr Press Publ. 469 p. (In Russian)
Babaev, Vladimir (ed.). 2002. Theory of State and Law. Moscow, Yurist Publ. 592 p. (In Russian)
Baranov, Vladimir. 2008. “Qualified silence of the legislator” as a general legal phenomenon: To the question of the essence and scope of the functioning of gaps in law. Probelyi v rossiyskom zakonodatelstve 1: 75–78. (In Russian)
Bakaeva, Irina. 2012. Personal non-property relations and non-material benefits in the context of the modernization of civil legislation. Zakony Rossii: opyt, analiz, praktika 12: 79–87. (In Russian)
Bartenev, Dmitry. 2009. Implementation of international standards in the field of incapacity and care in Eastern Europe. Nezavisimyiy psikhiatricheskiy zhurnal 4: 61–64. (In Russian)
Begichev, Boris. 1972. The legal capacity of Soviet citizens. Moscow, Yurid. Publ. 248 p. (In Russian)
Begichev, Boris. 1968. “On the legislative consolidation of the institution of representation in labor law”. Proceedings of the conference on the results of research work in 1967. Sverdlovsk: 138– 150. (In Russian)
Bond, Gary R., Robert E. Drake, Deborah R. Becker. 2012. The applicability of the US-developed model of individual employment and employment support in other countries. Vsemirnaia psikhiatriia. Ofitsial’nyi zhurnal Vsemirnoi psikhiatricheskoi assotsiatsii 1: 35–43. (In Russian)
Bondarenko, Elvira. 2003. Working capacity, legal capacity and legal facts. Zhurnal rossiyskogo prava 1: 61–69. (In Russian) Bondarenko, Elvira. 2015. The dynamics of labor relations. Moscow, NORMA, INFRA-M Publ. 192 р. (In Russian)
Dementjeva, Nadezhda, Kindras, Galina, Syrnikova, Bela, and Krasnovskaya, Еvgeniya. 2014. Conditions and types of work for persons with disabilities due to mental disorders in the rehabilitation system. Psikhicheskoe zdorovje 12 (7) (98): 56–61. (In Russian)
Drake, Robert, et al. 1999. A randomized controlled trial of supported employment for inner-city patients with severe mental illness. Archives of General Psychiatry 56: 627–633.
Eremina, Svetlana. 2011. Atypical subjects of labor law. Trudovoe pravo 1: 53–59. (In Russian)
Gervey, R., and Jeffrey R. Bedell. 1994. Supported employment in vocational rehabilitation. Bedell J. R. (ed). Psychological assessment and treatment of persons with severe mental disorders. Washington, Taylor & Francis: 151–175.
Gashkin, Aleksandr. 2009. Working capacity, legal capacity and legal facts. Trudovoe pravo 7: 102– 104. (In Russian)
Gur’yanova, Vera. 2015. On the definition of the concept of “legally relevant mental state”. Vestnik ehkonomiki, prava i sociologii 4: 191–194. (In Russian)
Karasaeva, Lyudmila, Kuzneczova, Anastasiya, and Lejbovich, Dzhenni. 2010. Modern aspects of employment of persons with neuropsychiatric diseases. Social’naya i klinicheskaya psikhiatriya 20 (1): 13–16. (In Russian)
Khokhlov, Еvgenij (ed.). 1996. The course of Russian labor law: Part of the total. In 3 vols, vol. 1. St. Petersburg, St. Petersburg University Publ. 573 p. (In Russian)
Kondratjeva, Еlena, and Barysheva, Galina. 2015. The genesis of productive labor. Internet-zhurnal Naukovedenie 3 (28): 43–45. (In Russian).
Korablina, Ol’ga. 2013. The ratio of labor and civil legal personality as legal categories. Gumanitarnye issledovaniya 2 (46): 130–136. (In Russian).
Kosenko, Nataliya, Krasil’nikov, Gennadij, Kosenko, Viktor, and Ageev, Mikhail. 2015. The origins of psychiatric stigma and its prospects. Kubanskij nauchnyj medicinskij vestnik 3 (152): 58–61. (In Russian).
Kotarev, Sergej. 2009. Citizen’s incapacity under Russian civil law: problems of theory and practice. Nauchnye vedomosti BelGU. Ser. Filosofiya. Sotsiologiya. Pravo 8 (63): 109–113. (In Russian).
Lazarev, Valerij. 2007. Technical and legal methods of concealing the legislative will. Yuridicheskaya tekhnika 1: 24–28. (In Russian).
Landyshev, Mikhail, Petrov, Dmitrij, and Konovalov, Oleg. 2015. Organization of medical and rehabilitation care for people with mental disorders (on the example of the Ryazan region). Vestnik RUDN. Ser. Meditsina 2: 32–38. (In Russian).
Lebedev, Vyacheslav (ed.). 2007. Modern labor law (experience of labor legal comparativism), vol. 1. Moscow, Statut Publ. 301 p. (In Russian).
Levina, Nelli, Lyubov, Еvgenij, and Rusakova, Galina. 2010. Labor and severe mental disorder: problems and solutions. Part 1. Sotsialnaya i klinicheskaya psikhiatriya 20 (1): 91–99. (In Russian)
Lushnikova, Marina, and Lushnikov, Andrej. 2006. Essays in the Theory of Labour Law. St. Petersburg, Yuridicheskiy tsentr Press Publ. 940 p. (In Russian)
Maksimova, Natal’ya, and Klimok, Natal’ya. 2016. Employment of persons with mental disorders on the example of the Tver region. Sotsialnaya i klinicheskaya psikhiatriya 26 (1): 67–71. (In Russian)
Mandzhiev, Aleksandr. 2017. Free will in contractual legal relations. Moscow, Statut Publ. 192 р. (In Russian)
Mitskevich, Aleksej. 1962. Subjects of Soviet law. Moscow, Gosyurizdat Publ. 213 p. (In Russian)
Paryagina, Ol’ga. 2017. Persons with mental disorders as subjects of an employment contract. Sibirskij yuridicheskij vestnik 2 (77): 48–55. (In Russian)
Ruzhenskaya, Еlena. 2016. Modern approaches to the organization of social rehabilitation of persons with mental disorders. Vestnik Ivanovskoj meditsinskoj akademii 21 (2): 10–15. (In Russian)
Serova, Ol’ga. 2016. Limitation of legal capacity (responsibility) of persons suffering from mental disorders: lack of consistency of norms in Russian law. Uchenye zapiski Kazanskogo universiteta. Ser. Gumanitarnye nauki 2: 436–442. (In Russian)
Shchennikova, Larisa. 2012. Property Relations in Civil Law: Theory and Practice. Vestnik Permskogo universiteta. Yuridicheskie nauki 1 (15): 165–175. (In Russian)
Shepel’, Tamara. 2010. Inter-sectoral problems of protecting the rights of persons with mental disorders. Vestnik OmGU. Ser. Pravo 3: 85–90. (In Russian)
Sinitsyn, Vladislav. 2013. On the issue of insanity, incapacity, limited capacity. Uchenye zapiski Kazanskogo universiteta. Ser. Gumanitarnye nauki 4: 218–226. (In Russian)
Sitdikova, Lyubov’, and Starodumova, Svetlana. 2016. Property responsibility of incapable persons. Sovremennoe pravo 8: 53–58. (In Russian)
Smirnov, Oleg. 1964. The nature and essence of the right to work in the USSR. Moscow, Yuridicheskaya literatura Publ. 210 p. (In Russian)
Usov, Grigorij, and Fedorova, Marina. 2006. Legal regulation of psychiatric care. Moscow: Yustitsinform Publ. 304 p. (In Russian)
Vasilev, Yurij. 2015. The qualified silence of the legislator as a general legal phenomenon: the statement of the problem. Yuridicheskaya nauka i praktika: vestnik Nizhegorodskoy akademii MVD Rossii 1: 227–230. (In Russian)
Yastrebov, Vasilij, Mitikhina, Irina, Mitikhin, Vyacheslav, Shevchenko, Lyubov’, Solokhina, Tat’yana. 2012. Mental health of the world’s population: the socio-economic aspect (according to foreign studies 2000–2010). Zhurnal nevrologii i psikhiatrii 2: 4–13. (In Russian)
Yavorchuk, Natal’ya. 2006. Legal guarantees provided to young people and their role in the regulation of relations in the labor sphere. Rossijskij ezhegodnik trudovogo prava 2: 331–352. (In Russian)
Zaitseva, Ol’ga. 2008. A strong criterion of employment legal personality and its importance in the legal regulation of labor relations. Pravo cheloveka na zhizn’ i garantii ego realizatsii v sfere truda i sotsial’nogo obespecheniya: mat-ly mezhdunar. nauch.-prakt. konf. Ed. by K. N. Gusov. Moscow: 239–242. (In Russian)
Zhil’tsov, Dmitrij. 2014. Productive labor and non-productive sphere of society. Upravlenie obrazovaniem: teoriya i praktika 3 (15): 71–80. (In Russian)
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Articles of "Pravovedenie" are open access distributed under the terms of the License Agreement with Saint Petersburg State University, which permits to the authors unrestricted distribution and self-archiving free of charge.
